Dehydrated Fish Treats for Dogs & Cats: Sardines vs Anchovies vs Bombay Duck (Bombil)

Fish treats are one of the most nutrient-dense, species-appropriate snacks you can add to your dog or cat’s diet — if you choose the right fish for the right purpose.

At The Doggos, we offer three single-ingredient dehydrated fish treats:

  • Dehydrated Sardines
  • Dehydrated Anchovies
  • Dehydrated Bombay Duck (Bombil)

They’re all natural, low-mercury, and preservative-free — but they are not interchangeable. Each serves a very different nutritional role.

This guide breaks down the differences so you can choose what actually suits your pet.

Why Choose Dehydrated Fish Treats for Dogs & Cats?

Dehydrated fish treats are:

  • Single-protein and highly digestible
  • Naturally rich in omega-3 fatty acids
  • Excellent for skin, coat, joints, and appetite
  • Free from grains, fillers, and additives

Unlike fresh or cooked fish, proper dehydration preserves nutrients without oils, salt, or seasoning, making it safe for both dogs and cats.

Dehydrated Sardines for Dogs & Cats

Best for skin, coat & joint support

Sardines are small, oily pelagic fish — which makes them an omega-3 powerhouse.

Nutritional profile:

  • Protein: ~22–25%
  • Fat: High (natural fish oils)
  • Omega-3: Very high
  • Mercury risk: Low (short lifespan)

Why choose sardines?

  • Supports dry or itchy skin
  • Improves dull coats
  • Helps joint mobility and inflammation
  • Great for senior pets or active dogs

Best for:

  • Dogs with skin issues or shedding
  • Pets needing joint support
  • Cats that enjoy oily fish flavours

Feeding frequency:
2–3 times per week (due to higher fat content)

Dehydrated Anchovies for Dogs & Cats

Best as a nutrient-dense topper & appetite booster

Anchovies are even smaller than sardines and incredibly nutrient-dense.

Nutritional profile:

  • Protein: ~26–29%
  • Fat: Moderate to high
  • Omega-3: Highly concentrated
  • Mercury risk: Very low

Why choose anchovies?

  • Extremely palatable — great for picky eaters
  • Strong aroma stimulates appetite
  • Dense nutrition in tiny portions

Best for:

  • Picky dogs and cats
  • Pets that need meal toppers
  • Short-term appetite support

Feeding frequency:
Occasional or in small quantities

Dehydrated Bombay Duck (Bombil) for Dogs & Cats

Best for daily feeding & sensitive stomachs

Bombay Duck (Bombil) is a lean ribbonfish species — very different from oily fish like sardines and anchovies.

Nutritional profile:

  • Protein: ~20–23%
  • Fat: Low
  • Omega-3: Moderate
  • Mercury risk: Very low (lean tissue)

Why choose Bombay Duck?

  • Lean protein = easy digestion
  • Lower fat makes it suitable for frequent feeding
  • Gentle on sensitive stomachs

Best for:

  • Dogs with digestive sensitivities
  • Pets on weight-management diets
  • Daily or frequent treat use
  • Cats that prefer milder fish flavours

Feeding frequency:
Can be fed more frequently than oily fish treats

Sardines vs Anchovies vs Bombay Duck: Quick Comparison

Choose sardines if:
You want skin, coat, and joint support.

Choose anchovies if:
You need a powerful topper or appetite stimulant.

Choose Bombay Duck if:
You want a lean, everyday fish treat that’s easy on the gut.

Many pet parents rotate all three — using Bombay Duck as a regular treat and sardines or anchovies strategically.

Are These Fish Treats Safe for Dogs & Cats?

Yes. All three fish:

  • Are naturally low in mercury due to size and lifecycle
  • Are dehydrated without preservatives or additives
  • Are suitable for both dogs and cats

Always adjust portion size based on your pet’s size, activity level, and overall diet.

Final Thoughts: Not All Fish Treats Are the Same

Fish treats aren’t just “protein snacks.”
They’re functional nutrition tools.

  • Sardines = omega-3 support
  • Anchovies = appetite & nutrient boost
  • Bombay Duck = lean, frequent feeding option

Choosing the right one — or rotating smartly — makes a visible difference in your pet’s health.